They state that every wish must be accounted for otherwise godchildren could secretly alter the very fabric of the universe, and Jorgen shows a clip about the last one made in December 19th, 1986 by a godchild named Joshua Applebee who secretly wished for Chuckles the Fairy Eating Cockatiel, which also caused massive destruction with its super powers, while telling about it. As Foop reveals the document to the council, they explain that a secret wish is the ultimate violation of Fairy Law. The council is brought to tears by this, and is about to rule in favor of Timmy, until Foop scrambles through Cosmo's stack of evidence and then finds a document labeled "Timmy's Secret Wish!". The most important wish, however, is how Timmy wished Poof into existence. The Council decides to see all the good Timmy has done, which includes helping his mom win the Miss Dimmsdale contest to make her feel pretty, as well as the same thing for his dad. Other wishes include Dark Laser, and Mark Chang. The first to be called is the Crimson Chin, who speaks in favor of Timmy at first, but then Foop shows the bad that Timmy caused to Crimson Chin, including turning his girlfriend evil and making him realize he is not actually real. Wanda begins to call various witnesses to the stand, past wishes that were brought to life by Timmy. Foop reasons that if Timmy loses then that means Poof would no longer exist because all of Timmy's wishes would have to be undone and he wants to see Timmy executed. To top it off, Cosmo accidentally brought stacks of evidence against Timmy.
Timmy gets to have a trial on whether or not he is "the Worst Fairy Godkid Ever", but Cosmo is his lawyer, and to make matters worse, Foop is the prosecuting attorney. Jorgen assures Timmy that the Fairy Council is inspecting all of them only to make the parade balloons and that Timmy shouldn't worry. The first thousand showcase the fires he caused, the following thousands show hurricanes, floods, and some plagues. In Fairy World, there is a parade to celebrate all of Timmy's wishes. Jorgen begins to sing the theme song, only to be shut down and have Timmy and his Fairies sing their own musical number, "A Million Wishes". Not long after they all go to Fairy World to begin a celebration. Once the millionth wish is made, Jorgen Von Strangle appears because he heard about the giant bacon. Timmy is doing his last batch of wishes to reach a million, which include giant bacon, giant balls, a unicycle riding bear and his own team of groupies.